Gift with a Story
ChatGPT Image Nov 2, 2025, 01_45_26 PM

Nutty Novelties – Small-Batch Nut Butters from Telford, PA

Posted on by mickdog100

Nutty Novelties

Nutty Novelty Peanut Butter

Small-Batch Nut Butters Crafted in Telford, PA

Nutty Novelties, based in Telford, Pennsylvania, creates some of the region’s most flavorful and innovative small-batch nut butters. Known for clean ingredients, handcrafted quality, and bold, creative flavors, Nutty Novelties has become a local favorite for anyone who values real food made with real care. Their commitment to freshness and craftsmanship makes them a natural fit for our curated, story-driven gift sets.

Nutty Novelties takes a simple approach:

  • Start with high-quality nuts

  • Grind them fresh in small batches

  • Keep ingredients clean and minimal

  • Create flavors that stand out in both taste and texture

Each jar reflects the brand’s passion for handcrafted quality and their dedication to using wholesome, straightforward ingredients without unnecessary additives.

Nutty Novelties – crafted in Telford, PA, and proudly featured in our curated gift sets.

Signature Peanut Butter Flavors

Buttersotch

Smooth and creamy and delicious and butterscotch-y, this one makes a great treat with carrots, in a butterscotch cupcake, or all by itself!

Chocolate

Yes, chocolate, and peanut butter...and chocolate! A tried and true combination, chocolate peanut butter makes a delicious spread on bagels, celery, sliced apples or, for a real treat, ice cream! It also works great for baking. And don't forget, it's still a great source of protein and fiber and it's 100% Vegan!

Cinnamon

Warm, comforting, and naturally sweet, Nutty Novelties Cinnamon Peanut Butter blends roasted North Carolina peanuts with a touch of real cinnamon for a flavor that tastes like dessert—but spreads like a snack. All-natural, small-batch, and free from fillers, it’s perfect on toast, apples, oatmeal, or straight from the spoon. A modern twist on a classic pantry favorite—simple ingredients, big flavor.

Habanero

A sweet-hot Peanut Butter and Caleb's new favorite! Made with our low-sugar Honey Roasted mixture and St. Lucifer's Habanero Blend, try this one on apples, or as the main ingredient in a Thai peanut sauce, or right off the spoon! The heat-lovers in your life will thank you

Honey Roasted

Delicious honey-roasted peanuts ground into sweet peanut butter. Now with less sugar and still a fantastic source of protein, honey-roasted peanut butter adds great flavor to a boring protein shake. Also goes great with a sliced banana on toast, or on hot waffles or pancakes.

Wild Espresso

Coffee fanatics, rejoice! Our fresh-from-the-roaster Wild Espresso Peanut Butter has a taste that's simply out of this world - that strong, sweet smell of freshly brewed coffee, mixed with cinnamon and peanut butter, bottled up in a jar! Using Backyard Beans Wild Espresso Roast Coffee, our new coffee-infused PB is like nothing you've ever had before. Indulge. Fall in love.

Tree Butter's

Almond Butter

A delicious spread made from a super-food! Nutty Novelties' almond butter is a great source of protein, fiber, vitamin E, potassium, iron and calcium and can be used to substitute peanut butter in any recipe.

Cashew Butter

Cashew Butter for the cashew lover! Literally just lightly salted cashews ground into nut butter, our cashew butter has a very rich flavor and can be used as a peanut butter stand-in for all your favorite recipes and snacks. Try it with some local honey on toast or an all-fruit spread on an English muffin.

Cinnamon Almond Butter

A much-adored nut butter, Cinnamon Almond combines two distinct flavors into a simply irresistible nutty spread. Always a big hit at parties, on pita chips or raw veggies, or right off a spoon all by yourself! We highly recommend it oatmeal too and it's only 4g of Sugar per serving!

Dark Chocolate Almond Butter

Dark Chocolate Almond Butter is as delicious as it sounds. Fresh roasted almonds ground into almond butter with just enough dark chocolate to make your taste buds smile, without sacrificing nutritional benefits. Makes a great dip for pretzels or pita chips, or as a great way to add flavor to your morning oatmeal. Plus it's 100% Vegan and only 4g of Sugar!

Pistachio Butter

It took us almost a full year but this one's now creamier and more spreadable and we can't make enough! A very unique nut butter, we recommend it on sliced cucumbers, gourmet cheeses, vanilla ice cream, even pasta and grilled salmon. So so good!

Seasonal Favorites

Pumpkin Spice

Sweet delicious Pumpkin Spice Peanut Butter is back! A creamy Peanut Butter made with butterscotch, cinnamon, and just enough pumpkin spice, it goes great in oatmeal, on pumpkin pancakes, pumpkin muffins, pumpkin bread,

A Natural Fit for Our Prohibition-Inspired Gift Sets

During the Prohibition era, families relied on homemade foods, pantry staples, and small-batch recipes to bring flavor to everyday life. Nut butters—nutritious, versatile, and long-lasting—were essential in many early 20th-century kitchens.

Nutty Novelties Peanut Butter Prohibition

Nutty Novelties fits seamlessly into our Prohibition-themed gift sets because they embody:

  • Craftsmanship over mass production

  • Simple, wholesome ingredients

  • Local Pennsylvania tradition

  • A nod to the home kitchens of the 1920s

Their bold, inventive flavors add a modern twist to the old-fashioned, small-batch spirit we celebrate.

Why We Love Partnering with Nutty Novelties

At Gift With a Story, we support businesses that value authenticity, flavor, and local craftsmanship. Nutty Novelties checks every box:

Nutty Novelty Peanuts Prohibition
  • Locally made in Telford, PA

  • Small-batch production for freshness and quality

  • Clean, simple ingredient lists

  • Flavors that elevate any breakfast or snack

  • A perfect complement to artisan coffee, teas, breads, and fruit butters

Their nut butters enhance both traditional and story-driven gift collections, from breakfast-themed boxes to Pennsylvania-made artisan bundles.

Nutty Novelties Speakeasy Collection:

Our curated gift sets proudly feature Nutty Novelties, the small-batch nut butter artisans from Telford, Pennsylvania. Known for their clean ingredients, bold flavors, and handcrafted quality, Nutty Novelties brings authentic Pennsylvania craftsmanship to every jar. These nut butters perfectly complement our story-driven gift collections—adding richness, creativity, and a deliciously modern twist to traditional, locally made foods.