Smuggle a little flavor into your pantry with The Bootlegger’s Tree Nut Butter Crate — a Prohibition-inspired gift set packed with small-batch, locally made tree nut butter, sealed in a small crate like it just came off a back-alley delivery truck in 1927.
Each crate includes two 8oz jars of handcrafted tree nut butter from Pennsylvania makers, and you choose the flavors — from smooth and classic to bold blends like Almond, Cashew, Dark Chocolate, and more (availability may vary seasonally).
This isn’t just a food gift… it’s a story in a crate. Perfect for foodies, history buffs, host gifts, or anyone who believes flavor should sometimes feel a little illegal.
Each gift set also comes with a story tailored to the occasion you choose, turning every bite into part of the experience itself.
Your choice of two delicious tree butters, allowing you to pick the flavors that best suit your tastes.
A delicious spread made from a super-food! Nutty Novelties' almond butter is a great source of protein, fiber, vitamin E, potassium, iron and calcium and can be used to substitute peanut butter in any recipe.
Ingredients: 100% Fresh Roasted Almonds
Cashew Butter for the cashew lover! Literally just lightly salted cashews ground into nut butter, our cashew butter has a very rich flavor and can be used as a peanut butter stand-in for all your favorite recipes and snacks. Try it with some local honey on toast or an all-fruit spread on an English muffin.
Ingredients: Fresh Roasted Cashews Salt
A much-adored nut butter, Cinnamon Almond combines two distinct flavors into a simply irresistible nutty spread. Always a big hit at parties, on pita chips or raw veggies, or right off a spoon all by yourself! We highly recommend it oatmeal too and it's only 4g of Sugar per serving!
Ingredients: Fresh Roasted Peanuts Cinnamon Drops (sugar, vegetable oil, cinnamon, non-fat dry milk, soy lecithin) Cinnamon
Dark Chocolate Almond Butter is as delicious as it sounds. Fresh roasted almonds ground into almond butter with just enough dark chocolate to make your taste buds smile, without sacrificing nutritional benefits. Makes a great dip for pretzels or pita chips, or as a great way to add flavor to your morning oatmeal. Plus it's 100% Vegan and only 4g of Sugar!
Ingredients: Fresh Roasted Almonds Sugar Chocolate Liquor Cocoa Butter Sunflower Lecithin
During the Prohibition era, everyday ingredients became the secret stars of underground cooking. When alcohol was outlawed and sugar was rationed, resourceful home bakers and speakeasy chefs leaned on pantry staples like nuts, honey, and roasted peanuts to create richly flavored treats that still felt indulgent—without breaking the law.
Nutty Novelties Peanut Butter carries that same rebellious tradition forward. Made in small batches right here in Pennsylvania, this all-natural peanut butter is crafted the way it would’ve been made back then—simple, pure ingredients, no fillers, no shortcuts, and no permission needed to enjoy.
Whether you're spreading it on warm toast, stirring it into speakeasy-style cocktails, or using it to recreate 1920s dessert recipes, Nutty Novelties turns any kitchen into a legal little rebellion of flavor.
Because in every era—then and now—the best things are made in small batches and shared in good company.
Small batch made. Naturally crafted. Historically delicious.
Whether you're celebrating a birthday, anniversary, graduation, sending sympathy, saying “get well soon,” or just letting someone know you're thinking of them, every gift from us becomes a fully curated experience. You choose the occasion, and we pair it with a custom Prohibition-inspired narrative that turns your gift set into a story—complete with themed language, era-style details, and a touch of 1920s mystery and charm.
Instead of a standard gift message, your recipient receives a personalized “secret delivery” note written as if it came from the hidden corners of a speakeasy…the backroom of a bootlegger’s shop…or a hush-hush courier who knew how to keep things quiet during the dry years of Prohibition.
You pick the occasion.
We deliver the experience—Prohibition style.
