New Hope Mills
The original mill was constructed by Judge Charles Kellogg, a prominent 19th-century figure who served in both the New York State Assembly and the U.S. Congress. Built with heavy timber framing and powered by water drawn from nearby ponds and waterfalls, this classic grist mill ground grain into fine flour for generations of local families and farmers. At a time when waterpower was the engine of American industry, New Hope Mills was part of a vibrant industrial landscape, one among 14 water-powered enterprises along Bear Swamp Creek in the mid-1800s.
Though the company moved its manufacturing operations to nearby Auburn, New York in the early 2000s to expand production, the original grist mill site remains a cherished landmark. It’s preserved with the intent of becoming a working museum where visitors can experience firsthand the sights, sounds, and stories of traditional milling. The site’s importance has been recognized with its listing on the National Register of Historic Places, affirming its role in the industrial and cultural history of Central New York.
Today, New Hope Mills continues to carry forward its legacy through premium pancake, muffin, scone, and cookie mixes enjoyed nationwide. But at its heart remains the same spirit that powered the original grist mill nearly two centuries ago: quality ingredients, craftsmanship rooted in history, and a connection to the community that has sustained it through generations.
Mixes
Banana Caramel Pancake Mix
Biscuit Mix
ButterMilk Pancake Mix
ButterMilk Pancake Mix
Chocolate Chip Pancake Mix
Country White Bread Mix
Has making your own bread ever felt intimidating? With our Country White Bread mix you can prepare your own fresh bread easily. This mix can be prepared by hand or with the help of a bread machine. Country White Bread is perfect served warm from the oven and spread with butter or sliced as sandwich bread.
Crepe Mix
Gluten Free Chia Seed Pancake Mix
Honey Cornbread Mix
Multi-grain Whole Wheat Pancake Mix
Old Fashioned Buckwheat Pancake Mix
Toasted Coconut
Syrup
Pancake Syrup
Our Pancake Syrup is unique because it is naturally made. Simply water, sugar, and Pure Maple Syrup! Unlike competitive brands that use high fructose corn syrup and artificial ingredients, we’re proud that our syrup is made with pure ingredients only. For your next breakfast, pair any of the New Hope Mills pancake mixes with New Hope Mills Pancake Syrup and you’ll be rewarded with many smiles!
1-12.5 oz Glass Bottle contains 22% Pure Maple Syrup Ingredients: Sugar, Water, Pure Maple Syrup. All natural, made with no synthetic colors or flavors.
Hot Chocolate
Hot Chocolate - Caramel
Hot Chocolate - Dark
Hot Chocolate - Peppermint
Hot Chocolate - Original
In the clandestine kitchens where flour dust lingers like cigarette smoke and the kettle’s whistle outrivals any jazz solo, there’s a pairing that whispers good taste in hushed, sophisticated tones. When the barrels roll and the law’s eye wanders elsewhere, the savvy home cook turns to the honest flavors of New Hope Mills and the artisanal richness of Bauman’s Fruit Butters to create dishes that would make even the toughest bootlegger tip his hat.
The mixes from New Hope Mills—born from over two centuries of mill-house tradition—bring hearty, dependable flour blends and classic breakfast bases that are as down-to-earth as a grain sack full of secrets. Whether it’s golden pancake batter ready to sizzle on the hot griddle or biscuit mix waiting to rise like a well-kept alibi, these blends are the foundation every home cook needs when spirits are high and appetite higher.
Now add a dollop of Bauman’s Fruit Butters, made in small batches with old-world Pennsylvania Dutch methods passed down since 1892. These aren’t your ordinary spreads; they’re concentrated, spice-kissed, orchard-sweet concoctions that require pounds of autumn fruit to yield a single jar of pure, luscious goodness—apple, cherry, plum, and more—cooked low and slow like a clandestine still hidden in the woods.
Picture this: stacks of golden pancakes, steaming hot, their tender crumb whispering of millstones turning by creekside, each layer kissed with a lavish swirl of apple or pumpkin butter—rich, tangy, and impossibly smooth. It’s the kind of decadent comfort that feels illicitly indulgent, as though you’ve slipped into a hidden room behind the bar for a taste only insiders get to savor.
Together, these two icons of heritage flavor—the foundational goodness of New Hope Mills and the bold, fruity character of Bauman’s butters—create a culinary duet that’s bold enough to stand up to rye whiskey, smooth enough to pair with your morning coffee, and timeless enough to turn every meal into a secret celebration.
New Hope Mills and Bauman's Gift Sets
Our gift sets featuring New Hope Mills mixes and Bauman’s fruit butters bring together generations of mill-house tradition and slow-cooked Pennsylvania Dutch craftsmanship in one unforgettable package. It’s the perfect pairing of hearty, golden-griddle goodness and rich, orchard-sweet spreads—made to turn any kitchen into a warm, nostalgic celebration.