Gift with a story

Fowler’s Mill

Fowler's Mill

Fowler's Mills

Sweet Comfort from Another Time

There’s a certain kind of sweetness that doesn’t need dressing up — the kind that comes from warm ovens, worn recipe cards, and the quiet hum of a kitchen doing things the right way. That’s the spirit behind Fowler's Mill, a place where tradition isn’t just remembered… it’s baked into every mix.

Tucked away in Ohio and known as one of the oldest continuously operating mills in the country, Fowler’s Mill has long been a destination for those who appreciate simple ingredients turned into something special. While the mill itself carries the grit and grind of American history, what truly sets it apart is its line of dessert-focused mixes — the kind that transform an ordinary evening into something worth gathering around.

We’re talking bubbling fruit crisps and cobblers, golden and syrupy as they come out of the oven… banana bread that fills the room with that unmistakable warm, sweet aroma… beer bread with a rustic edge and rich flavor… and muffins that rise soft and tender, ready for a pat of butter or a drizzle of something sweet.


These aren’t flashy desserts. They’re the kind that would’ve been served quietly behind closed doors during the Prohibition years — when the drinks were hidden, but the food was honest, comforting, and meant to be shared.

Mixes

Apple Crisp

Apple Crispalicious Cookie Mix

Cinnamon, oats, brown sugar, and cozy vibes in every spoonful. Our Apple Crisp Mix is your shortcut to homemade dessert greatness—just add sliced apples and butter. An easy choice to have kids to join in the baking on this one! Perfect for family dinners, potlucks, or whenever you’re craving something warm and comforting. Go ahead, let your kitchen soak up the smell of hot apple crisp, you won’t regret it.
Banana Bread Mix

Banana Bread Mix

Banana bread, but make it easy—and irresistible. Our Banana Bread Mix gives you that warm, moist, perfectly sweet loaf every time. Just add eggs, oil, milk, and those speckled bananas you’ve been saving, then bake up something delectable. Want to go wild? Toss in nuts or chocolate chips for an extra sweet treat. Perfect for breakfast, dessert, or gifting—if you can bear to share!
Beer Bread

Beer Bread Mix

Bread baking doesn’t get any easier—or tastier—than this. Our Beer Bread Mix transforms your favorite brew into a warm, hearty loaf with a golden crust and rich, malty flavor. Just crack a beer, stir, bake, and enjoy a rustic, bakery-style bread that pairs perfectly with soups, stews, and spreads. This is your jack-of-all-trades addition!
Blueberry Muffin Mix

Blueberry Muffin Mix

Ready to make mornings a little more delicious? Our Blueberry Muffin Mix bakes up moist, fluffy muffins with just the right touch of sweetness. Just add egg, milk, oil, and your favorite blueberries, and boom—you’re the breakfast hero. Bursting with flavor, these muffins are a berry good reason to get out of bed!
Double Apple Muffin Mix

Double Apple Muffin Mix

Apple lovers, rejoice! Our Double Apple Muffin Mix is loaded with cozy cinnamon spice and apple goodness in every bite. Just add milk, oil, applesauce or apple butter, and chopped apples for the ultimate muffin magic. Moist, flavorful, and totally addictive. No wonder it’s one of our best sellers!
Fruit Crisp

Fruit Crisp Mix

Crisp lovers, meet your new favorite go-to. Our Fruit Crisp Mix is a sweet, spiced topping made with cinnamon and oats—ready to be paired with whatever fruit you’ve got on hand. Just add butter, layer it over your choice of fruit, and bake up a cozy, crowd-pleasing dessert in no time.
Fruit Cobbler

Fruit Cobbler Mix

No matter the fruit, this cobbler mix brings the mhmm-mmm! Our Fruit Cobbler Mix is your go-to for a nostalgic, bubbling dessert that tastes just like Grandma used to make. Add milk, oil, and your favorite fresh or frozen fruit, then bake until golden and glorious. The crumbly top and juicy filling? A perfect match made in dessert heaven.

There’s something about a warm cobbler or fresh-baked bread that brings people together — no invitation needed. In the Roaring ’20s, when speakeasies thrived and doors stayed shut tight, it was food like this that made a house feel alive. A pan of crisp cooling on the counter, muffins stacked high, the smell of banana bread drifting through the air… it didn’t need a sign out front to draw a crowd.


That same spirit lives on in Fowler’s Mills mixes. They’re easy to make, hard to forget, and rooted in a time when dessert wasn’t just an afterthought — it was the main event.


Now add a generous spoonful of Bauman’s Fruit Butters, crafted in small batches using old-world Pennsylvania Dutch methods passed down since 1892. These aren’t your everyday spreads—they’re rich, spice-kissed, orchard-sweet creations, slow-cooked down to a thick, velvety finish using pounds of ripe fruit in every jar. Apple, cherry, plum, and more… each one as deep and full-bodied as a well-kept secret.


Picture this: a bubbling fruit crisp or cobbler fresh from the oven, its golden topping crisped just right, or a slice of warm banana bread or muffin, soft and fragrant. Now finished with a generous layer of fruit butter melting right into every bite—sweet, tangy, and smooth as silk. It’s the kind of comfort that feels just a little indulgent… like something meant to be enjoyed quietly behind closed doors.


Together, the dessert-driven charm of Fowler’s Mills mixes and the bold, fruit-forward richness of Bauman’s butters create a pairing that’s as timeless as it is satisfying—simple ingredients, elevated into something worth gathering around, whether it’s a quiet morning or a backroom celebration.

Fowler's Mill and Bauman's Gift Sets

At Gift With a Story, we don’t just include products — we include the stories behind them. Fowler’s Mills fits right in with that mission: a historic mill with a passion for baking mixes that turn simple moments into lasting memories.


So whether you’re baking up a crisp for the family, whipping together muffins for a quiet morning, or putting together a dessert spread that would make any bootlegger proud… you’re not just making something sweet.


You’re bringing a little piece of history back to the table.